On a book page, this tab will allow you to add a book to one of your lists.
Please login or register to use this feature.
9780271016948_cover Enlarge Cover
0 of 5
0 ratings
rated!
rated!
list price: $91.95
edition:Hardcover
also available: Paperback
published: Oct 1997
ISBN:9780271016948

Appeal to Expert Opinion

Arguments from Authority

by Douglas Walton

reviews: 0
tagged:
add a tag
Please login or register to use this feature.
rhetoric, criticism, logic
0 of 5
0 ratings
rated!
rated!
list price: $91.95
edition:Hardcover
also available: Paperback
published: Oct 1997
ISBN:9780271016948
Description

A new pragmatic approach, based on the latest developments in argumentation theory, analyzing appeal to expert opinion as a form of argument.

Reliance on authority has always been a common recourse in argumentation, perhaps never more so than today in our highly technological society when knowledge has become so specialized—as manifested, for instance, in the frequent appearance of "expert witnesses" in courtrooms. When is an appeal to the opinion of an expert a reasonable type of argument to make, and when does it become a fallacy? This book provides a method for the evaluation of these appeals in everyday argumentation.

Specialized domains of knowledge such as science, medicine, law, and government policy have gradually taken over as the basis on which many of our rational decisions are made daily. Consequently, appeal to expert opinion in these areas has become a powerful type of argument. Challenging an argument based on expert scientific opinion, for example, has become as difficult as it once was to question religious authority.

Walton stresses that even in cases where expert opinion is divided, the effect of it can still be so powerful that it overwhelms an individual's ability to make a decision based on personal deliberation of what is right or wrong in a given situation. The book identifies the requirements that make an appeal to expert opinion a reasonable or unreasonable argument. Walton's new pragmatic approach analyzes that appeal as a distinctive form of argument, with an accompanying set of appropriate critical questions matching the form. Throughout the book, a historical survey of the key developments in the evolution of the argument from authority, dating from the time of the ancients, is given, and new light is shed on current problems of "junk science" and battles between experts in legal argumentation.

 

Contributor Notes

Douglas N. Walton is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Winnipeg. He has published two books with Penn State Press, The Place of Emotion in Argument (1992) and Arguments from Ignorance (1995). Other recent books of his include Slippery Slope Arguments (1992) and Plausible Arguments in Everyday Conversation (1992).

 

Out of print

This edition is not currently available in bookstores. Check your local library or search for used copies at Abebooks.

Reader Reviews

Sign Up or Sign In to add your review or comment.

Related Blog Posts

Other Titles by Douglas Walton

The New Dialectic

The New Dialectic

Conversational Contexts of Argument
edition:Paperback
also available: eBook
tagged : logic
More Info

Argument Structure

A Pragmatic Theory
edition:eBook
More Info

User Activity

X
Contacting facebook
Please wait...